top of page

One of Us Is Lying

Karen M. McManus

Step into the gripping world of high school drama and mystery with Karen M. McManus' 'One of Us Is Lying,' a novel that combines suspense, intrigue, and social commentary. This essential study guide will help you explore the themes, characters, and plot twists that make 'One of Us Is Lying' a standout in young adult fiction.


'One of Us Is Lying' follows the lives of five high school students who walk into detention; but only four walk out alive. What unfolds is a thrilling whodunit that delves into the secrets, lies, and hidden truths that bind and divide them. McManus' novel is a compelling exploration of the pressures and dynamics of teenage life.


Whether you're a fan of mystery novels, young adult fiction, or simply love a good twist, this guide will enhance your understanding of the novel's key elements and the factors that have contributed to its success.

Summary of the Book

'One of Us Is Lying' by Karen M. McManus is a young adult mystery novel that begins with five high school students - Bronwyn, Addy, Nate, Cooper, and Simon - walking into detention. However, Simon, the creator of a gossip app that reveals the secrets of Bayview High's students, dies under suspicious circumstances before detention ends. The remaining four students become prime suspects in what is now a murder investigation.


As the story unfolds, each of the four students is revealed to have secrets that Simon was planning to expose. The novel alternates between the perspectives of the four main characters, creating a complex web of lies, truths, and half-truths. As the investigation deepens, alliances are formed, and the characters must confront their own flaws and insecurities.


The novel culminates in a shocking twist that reveals the true circumstances of Simon's death and the consequences of the lies that were told. 'One of Us Is Lying' is a suspenseful and thought-provoking novel that examines the impact of secrets and the pressure to conform to societal expectations.

Key Themes & Motifs

One of the central themes in 'One of Us Is Lying' is the impact of secrets and lies. The novel explores how hidden truths can shape and destroy lives, as each character's secret is gradually revealed and their world begins to unravel. This theme is closely tied to the idea of identity and the pressure to conform to societal norms, particularly in the high school setting.

Another key theme is the nature of truth and perception. The novel highlights how easily facts can be distorted and how perceptions can be manipulated, both by individuals and by social media. This theme is explored through the various twists and turns of the plot, as well as through the characters' interactions with each other and the outside world.

The theme of justice is also significant, as the characters grapple with the consequences of their actions and the legal and moral implications of Simon's death. The novel raises questions about guilt, responsibility, and the pursuit of justice in a world where the lines between right and wrong are often blurred.

Additionally, 'One of Us Is Lying' delves into the dynamics of high school life, exploring issues such as peer pressure, bullying, and the desire for acceptance. These themes resonate with readers and add depth to the novel's mystery, making it a compelling exploration of teenage life and the complexities of human behaviour.

Analysis of Main Characters

Bronwyn Rojas is one of the central characters, known as the 'brain' of the group. She is intelligent, ambitious, and determined to succeed, but her involvement in the investigation forces her to confront her own vulnerabilities and the pressure she feels to be perfect.

Nate Macauley, the 'criminal,' has a troubled past and a reputation for being a bad boy. His character is more complex than he initially appears, and the novel reveals the struggles he faces behind his tough exterior. Nate's relationship with Bronwyn adds an emotional layer to the story, highlighting the theme of trust and redemption.

Addy Prentiss, the 'princess,' is initially portrayed as a stereotypical popular girl, but her character undergoes significant development as she learns to assert her independence and challenge the expectations placed on her. Addy's journey is one of self-discovery and empowerment.

Cooper Clay, the 'athlete,' is another key character who struggles with the pressure to live up to others' expectations. His storyline explores themes of identity, acceptance, and the challenges of being true to oneself in the face of external pressures.

Simon Kelleher, the victim, is a pivotal character whose actions and motivations drive the plot. Although Simon dies early in the story, his presence looms large over the narrative as the characters grapple with the fallout of his secrets. The interplay between these characters creates a rich and layered narrative that keeps readers engaged and invested in their journeys.

Setting & Social Context

'One of Us Is Lying' is set in the fictional Bayview High, a typical American high school where the social dynamics and pressures of teenage life play a central role in the story.

The setting is crucial to the novel's exploration of themes such as peer pressure, bullying, and the impact of social media on young people's lives. The high school setting also serves as a microcosm of society, where the characters' actions and decisions are influenced by the expectations and judgments of their peers.

The novel's contemporary setting reflects the realities of modern teenage life, including the pervasive influence of technology and social media. The setting and historical context of the novel are integral to its themes and plot, as they provide the backdrop for the characters' struggles and the unfolding mystery. McManus's depiction of high school life is both realistic and relatable, making the novel resonate with readers who have experienced similar pressures and challenges.

Writing Style & Narrative Techniques

Karen M. McManus' writing in 'One of Us Is Lying' is characterised by its engaging prose, multiple perspectives, and skillful use of suspense. The novel is told from the alternating viewpoints of the four main characters, allowing readers to see the story from different angles and to piece together the mystery alongside the characters. This narrative technique creates a sense of immediacy and intimacy, drawing readers into the characters' inner thoughts and emotions. McManus' use of short chapters and cliffhangers at the end of each chapter keeps the pacing brisk and the tension high.

The dialogue is sharp and realistic, capturing the voices of the teenage characters and adding authenticity to their interactions. The novel's plot is intricately woven, with each revelation building on the last to create a complex and satisfying mystery. McManus' writing also explores deeper themes of identity, justice, and the impact of secrets, making the novel not only a compelling thriller but also a thought-provoking exploration of the human experience.

Overall, McManus' writing in 'One of Us Is Lying' is both accessible and sophisticated, making it a standout in the genre of young adult fiction.

Important Quotes & Analysis

'One of Us Is Lying' is filled with memorable quotes that capture the essence of its themes and characters. Here are some of the most significant and impactful quotes from the book:


  • "Everyone's got secrets, right?" - This quote encapsulates the novel's central theme of secrets and the impact they can have on individuals and relationships.


  • "Things'll get worse before they get better." - This quote reflects the novel's exploration of the challenges and difficulties the characters face as they navigate the complexities of the investigation and their own lives.


  • "They think I'm weak, and maybe I am. But maybe I'm stronger than anyone knows." - This quote highlights the theme of self-discovery and empowerment, particularly in the character arc of Addy.


These quotes and many others throughout the novel serve to highlight the depth and emotional resonance of McManus's characters and their experiences. By examining these significant passages, readers can gain a deeper understanding of the book's core ideas and the ways in which they resonate with themes of identity, justice, and the impact of secrets.

Conclusion & Final Thoughts

Karen M. McManus' 'One of Us Is Lying' is a compelling and suspenseful novel that combines the best elements of mystery, drama, and social commentary.

Through its exploration of secrets, lies, and the complexities of teenage life, the novel offers a thought-provoking reflection on the pressures and dynamics of modern society. The novel's engaging characters, intricate plot, and skillful writing make it a standout in the genre of young adult fiction.

McManus's ability to weave together multiple perspectives and create a narrative that is both thrilling and emotionally resonant makes 'One of Us Is Lying' a must-read for fans of mystery and contemporary fiction. The novel's enduring popularity and critical acclaim are a testament to its power to captivate and challenge readers, making it a modern classic in the world of young adult literature.

bottom of page